律师风云 第01季结案陈词.docx

《律师风云 第01季结案陈词.docx》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《律师风云 第01季结案陈词.docx（20页珍藏版）》请在淘文阁 - 分享文档赚钱的网站上搜索。

1、律师风云第01季结案陈词BOSTONLEGAL经典结案陈词第一季第一集黑人女孩Sarah因被拒绝扮演白人孤儿Annie这一角色而诉至法庭，并聘请AlanShore为其律师。BradChase与AlanShore以本案的结局打赌，但AlanShore对此却没有自信心。闲谈中，DennyCrane告诉Alan要“Pullarabbitoutofyourhat.Thatsthesecretofbothtriallawandlife.翌日，庭审即将结束时，一名不速之客忽然闯入(Courtroom)SarahToomy:“.whenImstuckwithadaythatsgrayandlonely;Ij

2、uststickoutmychinandgrinandsaytomorrow,tomorrow,Iloveyatomorrow,yourealwaysadayaway.JudgeRitaSharpley:Thankyou.Thatwas.SarahToomy:continuing,withAlanShoremouthingthewordsalongwithher“Tomorrow,tomorrow,Illloveyatomorrow.Yourealwaysadayaway.AlanShoreclaps,grinningasifHEisthestagemotherAlanShore:Thatwa

3、sgreat!JudgeRitaSharpley:Sarah,thatwasmagnificent.Buttheotherlittlegirlwasquitegood,too.Andgiventhediscretionthathastobeallowedtoproducersinthesesituations.AlanShore:YourHonor,wehavesomethingcalledtheEqualProtectionClause,wehavesomethingcalledthe14thAmendmentIbelieveitsactuallyrequiredreadingforjudg

4、es.Icouldbewrongthere.ReverendAlSharpton(frombehindAlan):CouldIbeheard,yourHonor?Iheardaboutthismatter.IwouldliketoaddressthiscourtonwhatIconsider.JudgeRitaSharpley:Imsorry,Reverend,butyouhavenostandinghere.ReverendAlSharpton:IhavestandingasanAmericancitizenspeakinguponacivilrightsviolation.JudgeRit

5、aSharpley:ReverendSharpton,Iwillaskyoutostepdown.ReverendAlSharpton:IhavestandingasBobbyKennedyhadstanding,.JudgeRitaSharpley:Youhavenostandinginthismeeting.ReverendAlSharpton:.onthestepsofthecourthouseinAlabama!JudgeRitaSharpley:Nooneisdenyingthislittlegirlaneducation,sir.ShejustcantplayAnnie.Rever

6、endAlSharpton:Youmaythinkthisisasmallmatter.Butthisisnosmallmatter.ThischildisbeingdeniedtherighttoplayanAmericaniconbecauseshedoesntmatchthedescription.Thosedescriptionswerecrafted50yearsago!Weresupposedtobeinadifferentday!JudgeRitaSharpley:Reverend.ReverendAlSharpton:Youtalkaboutracialequality,how

7、weremakingprogress.Theproblemwiththatprogressisitsalwaysadayaway.Tomorrow,tomorrowyoulovethat!becauseitsalwaysadayaway.Imheretostickoutmychintoday!Today!GiveusanAfrican-AmericanSpiderMan!Giveusablackthatcanrunfasterthanaspeedingbulletandleapovertallbuildingsinasinglebound!Nottomorrowtoday!Today!Thes

8、unneedstocomeouttoday!Nottomorrow,yourHonor!GodAlmighty!GivetheAmericanpeopleablackOrphanAnnie.Itsjustnotgoodenoughtosayshedoesntlookthepart.ApplausefromthespectatorsgalleryReverendAlSharpton:toAlanShoreThatswhatyoucallarabbit,son.DennyCrane.第二集Carrie因其丈夫在一次手术中死亡而将他的医生Dr.Mahoney告上了法庭，要求获得精神损害赔偿，Denn

9、yCrane在庭外取证时屡次问及Carrie丈夫逝世后的性生活，因此惹怒了Carrie及其律师KevinRipley，他们提出了对Denny的制裁申请，Denny坚持本人辩护，而合伙人也想趁此时机把他赶出律所。(Courtroom)Atty.KevinRipley:Idontknowifhewastryingtohumiliateherorhitonher.Itwasntclear.Whatwasclearwastheindecencyofit.Thisiswhatlawyeringhasdegeneratedto.CarrieLansinglostherhusband.Hesprobingh

10、erabouthersexlife.Itwasablatantabuseofourprocess.Itwasanembarrassmenttotheintegrityofourprofession.Thisattorneyshouldbesanctionedseverely,yourhonor.Amessagehastobesenttothebar,thatourbarisraisedhigherthananepisodeofrealitytelevision.DennyCranedemeanedCarrieLansing.Hedemeanedourcourtsystem,andheshoul

11、dbedealtwith.JudgeMorganBaker:Mr.Crane?BradChase:Denny,Ihaveagoodfeelforthis.CanItakeit?DennyCrane:Illtakeit.Lookingatjudge.Thisis,um,prettypowerfulstuff.IcanseeMr.Ripleysaverypowerfulman.Andthatsabigthingwithlawyers,isntit?Power.Fearoffeelingweak.Iveseenitbefore.AttorneyscomingupagainstDennyCrane.T

12、heyjumpandstompandshaketheirfistsandbellowwithimpassionedrage.Itmakesquiteademonstration,doesntit?Whenyoucutthroughthemerits,thisladyhasallegedinhercomplaintlossofconsortium.Legaltermsmeaningsexandaffection.Andifshesenjoyingsexandaffection,itsrelevant.Itsamitigatingfactor.Imentitledtoexploreit.Mr.Ri

13、pleymaynotlikeit,butitslegitimate.And,Imayadd,thatIconductedmyprobeintherelativeprivacyofaclosedconferenceroom.Mr.PowerfulManmadeitmuchmorepublicwithhisimpassionedchest-thumpinginacourtroom.Atty.KevinRipley:Iobjecttothis.DennyCrane:Oh,goaheadandpoundthetable.IlltellyouwhatIobjectto.Wehaveanofferonth

14、etableyousolovetopound.AnofferIcantdiscussbecausethesettlementtalkshavebeensealed.Sufficeittosayitsonthehighside,theextremehighside,consideringthefactthatliabilityisnotcertain.Mr.Lansinghadapreexistingheartcondition.Butinsteadoftakingtheoffer,powerfulguyslikeMr.Ripleywanttogototrial.Why?BecauseImthe

15、opponent.Itsacouptobeatthebigguy.Well,whatifyoudont?Youdemeantheprofession,Mr.PowerfulGuy.Youreusingyourclienttogetanotch.YouremakingCarrieLansinggothroughtheordealofatrialforyourownego.Atty.KevinRipley:Objection!DennyCrane:Atrialyoumaylose,inwhichcaseshegetsnothing!Atty.KevinRipley:Objection!DennyC

16、rane:Oh,butifyoureloudenoughAtty.KevinRipley:Objection!DennyCrane:Forcefulenoughandstrongenough,shemayneverrealizethatyoublewit.TheCP&SattorneysarelookingatDenny.Bradsmilesslightly.第三集1.WendyMoore与她的上司Mr.Ralston曾有过一段婚外情，她想结束这段感情，而Mr.Ralston却纠缠不放，无奈之下WendyMoore提起了性骚扰诉讼。WendyMoore找到Alan作他的代理人，而Mr.Rals

17、ton的代理人却是Alan的前女友ChristinePauley。(InsidethecourtroomofAlanstrial.Heisclosing.)AlanShore:Somepeoplesimplycannotletgo.Youloveapersonsodesperately.Youperhapsbegintolosesightofreason.Andyoubegintoactunreasonably,perhapsoutofcontrol,even.ItspossibleDanielRalstonhadnocontroloverhisbehavior.Maybehetrulycou

18、ldntstoppursuingWendyMoore.Maybehehadtokeepcalling.Hadtoschedulethoselunches.Hadtoseeminglystalkher,ifyouwill.Hewasinlovewithher.Peopleinlovelosetheirgrip.AtthispointAlanturnsandlooksatChristinestable.Butwhatsatissuehereisherstateofmind.Hermentalstate.NotMr.Ralstonsstateofmind.ButWendys.Christinesqu

19、irmsinherchairalittlebit.Wasshereasonablyupsetbythisrelentlesspursuit?Shesamarriedwomanwithafamily,tryingtosalvagehermarriageandherbosskeepscalling.Keepscoming.Keepscoming.Keepspropositioningher.Thefactthatsheoncelovedthismanonlymakesitworse.Moredifficult.Whatchoicedidshereallyhavebuttoleave?Maybeth

20、atwashisplanallthetime.Heknewhecouldntfireher.Maybethatwashispsychologicalgame.Wheretheonlythingshecouldreallydointheendwasgetinhercar,anddriveoff.Hecreatedahostileworkingenvironmentwithrepeated,unwelcomedsexualadvances,ladiesandgentlemen.Thatisprimafacieclassicsexualharassment.Alanturnsfromthejurya

21、ndsitsdownathistable.Christinestandsuptobegin.ChristinePauley:Lovehappensintheworkplaceallthetime.Infact,itswheremostaffairsstart.Mostrelationships.Ithappens.Sodobreakups.Asawoman,Iamoffendedbytheonslaughtoftheselawsuits.Asneutralasthelanguagemaybe,sexualharassmentlawisgenderbiased.Itexiststoprotect

22、woman.Itfeedsintotheperceptionthatwomenareweakerthan.Itgoesallthewaybacktocommonlawwherewomenweredeniedtherighttoenterintocontractsbecausewelackedmentalcapacity.Todaysharassmentlawisdesignedtoprotectusfromsexualbanterintheworkplacebecausewejustcanttakeit.Icantakeit.Canyou?Canyou?Dowereallyneedtoclea

23、nsetheworkplaceofallsexualexpressionsothatitllbesafeforus?Theselawstreatusasifwewereeitherpsychologicallyoremotionallyimpaired.AndImsickofit.Aresomecaseslegitimate?Absolutely.Buthere,thiswomanisagrownup.Sheenteredintoanadultconsensualrelationshipwithherboss.Itended.Perhapsbumpy.Heshurt.Hesstillinlov

24、e.Soshesues.Shewasntfired.Sheisacollege-educatedvicepresidentofabrokeragefirm.Shes34yearsold.Shesaprofessional.Shesheretodaytotellyouthatshecantstickupforherself.Sheisheretodaytryingtotakeadvantageofalawthatdeclareswomentobetheweakersex.Notforme,ladiesandgentlemen.Iwouldnthavegotteninmycaranddriveno

25、ff.Idhavesoonerdrivenoverhim.Alanchuckles.Letstreatthesepeoplebothofthemasiftheyweregrown-ups.Shesitsdown.2.Sally的第一次庭审，律所又派WalterSeymore来对她进行考察，这让Sally不知所措。Alan告诉她要“Pullarabbitoutfromunderyourdress，给陪审团讲故事，逗他们乐，然后把故事和案子联络起，再请求他们放人。第二天，庭审现场，Sally果然讲起了故事Thenextday,insideSallyscourtroomtrial.Theopposi

26、ngattorneyisfinishingherclosing.D.A.Huff:Amanwithfelonypriorsforrobberyandburglary.Butthistime,hestolethewalletbymistake.Sure.Shesitsdown.Sallystandsup,turnsaroundandseesWalterSeymorelookingather,thenturnsaroundandbeginsherclose.SallyHeep:Oneday,Iwasinmykitchen.IthinkIwasabout15.AndincameFred,mybigc

27、hocolateLab.Andinhismouthwasadeadrabbit.Theneighborspetrabbit.AndIthought“ThisisitforFred.Iftheyfindouthekilledtheiradoredpet,AnimalControlwouldbedown,and-.So,Itooktherabbit.Washedhimoffinthesink.Pulledouttheblowdryer.Gothimallwhiteandfluffylooking.AndIsnuckovertomyneighborsbackyardandIputhimbackinh

28、iscage,hopingtheydthinkhediedofnaturalcauses.Thatnightmyparentscameintomyroom.Theneighborspetrabbithaddiedthreedaysago,theytoldme.Theyburiedhiminthewoods.Andsomewackoevidentlydughimup,washedhimoff,andputhimbackinthecage.(Afewjurorsaresmiling).ButIrememberthinkingtomyselfthetruthisnotonlystrangerthan

29、fiction,butoftenlessbelievable.Andthatswhatwehavehere,ladiesandgentlemen.Thelogicalversion,Isuppose,isthatmyclientstolethatwallet.Thelessbelievable,butquitepossiblytrueaccount,isthathemistookitforhisown.Nobody,notoneofus,canbesureitdidnthappenexactlythewayRamoneValesquezsaiditdid.Thatsreasonabledoub

30、t.WalterSeymoreissmiling.Sallyreturnstohertableandsitsdownnexttoherclient.第四集Edwin私自从精神病院跑出来并以律所名义接了一个谋杀案，毫无刑事案件经历的Lori将和他一起办理此案。Thenextday,insideEdwinandLoriscourtroom.ADAWilliamPrestonisclosing.ADAWilliamPreston:YouheardfromwitnessFrankSimmonswhosawanS.U.V.speedbyhimamilefromthescenearoundthetimeo

31、fthemurder.Withalicenseplatebeginningwith3-L-6.Mr.LitchsS.U.V.hasalicenseplatebeginningwith3-L-6.Andwhenthepoliceenteredthedefendantsapartment,whatdidhedo?Hedidntask“Whatsthisabout?Hedidntsay,“Hey,whatsgoingon?Heknewexactlywhytheywerethere,andheimmediatelybeganhisescape.Andtheninthehospital,heconfes

32、sed.Itwasntadelusionalconfession.Hedescribedafactpatternthatwascompletelyconsistentwiththecrime.Thedefendantadmittedthathewasafraidofyetanotherdrugconvictionthatwouldlandhimalifesentence.Hepanicked,pulledoutagun,andfired.Now,hislawyerssuggesthewas,perhaps,delusionalwhenheconfessedorthathesimplyliedt

33、oprotecttherealkiller.Afriendoralovedone.Desperatesuggestionsforadesperateclient.Itsinsultingtothiscourt,toyou,andespeciallytothatwomanandhertwochildren.WarrenLitchmurderedherhusband.WarrenLitchkilledtheirfather.Headmittedtothepolicethathedidso.Letsnotwasteanymoretime.Hesitsdown.LorilookstoEdwin,but

34、hesnotmoving.LoriColson:Edwin?Itsyourturn.Edwin(whisperingtoher):Ifellasleeplastnightandforgottoprepareaclosing.Imeanttotellyou.LoriColson:Youdonthaveaclosing?EdwinPoole:No.Doyou?JudgePeterHarding:Counsel?LoriColson:Edwin,youvegotnothing?Edwinslowlyrisestohisfeet.EdwinPoole:WhenIwasalittleboy,myfath

35、ersaidtomeIcanstillhearhisvoiceLorijumpstoherfeet.LoriColson:Ibelievehesaid“ladiesfirst.Edwinsitsdown.LoriColson:Idontknowaboutyou,butifIhearthatsomeoneconfessedtoacrime,thenIjustassumehesguilty.ButifIheartheconfessioniscoerced,then-.Forexample,youcouldhaveamanbleedingoutwithastomachwound,puthiminar

36、oomwithpoliceandclergywhokeepinsistingtohimthathedidsomethingandhemightactuallycometobelieveit.Andgee,whatifitwasafriendoralovedonewhowasdrivingWarrenscarthatnight?ThatwouldexplainwhyWarrenwastryingtoflee,wouldntit?Helikelyknewthepolicewerecomingtomistakenlyarresthim.Didthepoliceinvestigateanyofthis

37、?MyGod,weallassumeWarrenLitchisguilty.Butwhatifheisnt?Now,letsturntotheotherevidence.Wait.Thereisnootherevidence.Nogun,nowitnesses,nofibers,noforensics.Alltheyhaveisthatcoercedconfession.Now,youmightthinkhedidit.Andifyouredetermined,youcanevenstillassumeit,Isuppose.Butifyouretoupholdthelawanddemandp

38、roofbeyondallreasonabledoubt,andifwedontdemandthat,dowereallywanttosendamessagetothepolice?“Hey,forgettheevidence.Justbringusthatconfession.Lorisitsdown.第五集某人假想本人得了某些疾病，向医生寻求帮助，医生治疗了他半年，不过并没有本质性的效果，由于他不过是普通的头痛并且患有典型的抑郁症，但医生还是每次向他收取费用，于是病人决定起诉医生InJudgePaulResnickscourtroom,theattorneysaremakingclosin

39、garguments.AttorneyBraxtonMason:Itsbadenoughthatpatientsarerunningtothecourtssuingtheirdoctorsforalltheirills.Nowwehaveonesuingforhisimaginedills.Thiscaserepresentstheheightinfrivolouslitigation.Whatsnext?Seekingdamagesforabaddream?Ihopenot.AlanShore:“Frivolous.Isthatwhathesaid?“Frivolous?Astonishin

40、g.Thisman,whosuffers,dayinanddayout,frommigrainessoexcruciatinghecannotwork,cantendure10minutesathiscomputer-atrainedsoftwareengineer.Andhereheissubjectinghimselftodepositions,toexaminations,thelaborious,mindnumbingblatherofattorneys.Allforwhat?Frivolity?ForsixmonthsBillMorganreachedouttohisdoctor,w

41、eekafterweek,eachtimeinvoicedforthousandsandthousandsofdollarsinsum.Andtheneachtimedismissed,pattedontheheadandsentonhisway.HadMr.Morganactuallyreceivedtherightmedicalcare,orevenbeendirectedtoadoctorwhocouldspecificallygivehimthatcare,psychiatricorotherwise,hiscurrentstatewouldmostlikelyhavebeenalle

42、viated.Butthedefendantcouldntbebotheredtocare.AsDr.Rayburntoldyouhimself,hetreatedBillMorganlikeamascot.Opposingcounselregardshimasanuisance.Hesahumanbeing.Hesahumanbeing.Weteachourchildrenthateveryoneisentitledtorespectanddignity.Howpatheticitiswhenadultscantabidesuchabasiclessoninhumanity.Howuncon

43、scionable.第八集一个圣诞老人的扮演者因是同性恋而遭到辞退，于是将他的老板告上了法庭，由于法官的偏见，Alanshore对本案失去了自信心，于是他又求助于ReverendAlSharpton.ReverendAlSharpton:Sorry,Imlate,Judge.Illmakethisquick.AlanShore:Andsubtle.JudgeHarryHingham:Whothehellareyou?ReverendAlSharpton:TheimageofSantaClaushasbeencraftedforhundredsandhundredsandhundredsofye

44、ars,butweresupposedtobeinadifferentday.GivetheworldablackSantaClaus.LetthepeoplehaveanAfrican-Americancomedownthechimneybearingjoyandgoodwill.AlanShore:sotovocetoAlSharptonGay,notblack.ReverendAlSharpton:Theprejudiceagainstgaypeoplemuststop.Weallsaywereforgayrights.Weallsayweaccepthomosexuality.Butg

45、iveagaymanahug,sitinhislap.JudgeHarryHingham:Whoisthisman?ReverendAlSharpton:LetthebellsoftoleranceringoutthisChristmas.AlanShore,havingwrittenthisspeech,ismouthingthewordswithReverendAlSharptonReverendAlSharpton:Letpeopleopentheirmindsastheyopentheirpresentsunderneaththetree.Weneedyourmind,judge,to

46、day.Letthegaymanbemybrother,beyourbrother,betheschoolteacher,betheconstructionworker!GivetheworldagaySantaClaus!GodAlmighty.AlanShoreiscountingthemonhisfingers.GodAlmighty,GodAlmighty.LeaveoutthecookiesandthemilkthisChristmasEveforaholly,jollyhomosexual!GodAlmighty!AlanShore:Andcut.Thegallerybreaksi

47、ntoapplauseandcheers.ReverendAlSharpton:Ithrewinoneextra.AlanShore:Thankyou.第十一集U.S.Court:HallwayReporter:TheretheyareAbarrageofquestionsfromalargegroupofreportersReporter:Couldyouansweraquestion,sir?LoriColson,PaulLewiston,ShirleySchmidt,DennyCrane,BradChase,SallyHeepandJohnZenawiareexitingtheeleva

48、torPaulLewiston:Nocomment.Wehavenocommentatthistime.Wellbemakingacommentafterthemotion.DennyCrane:IeatCocoaPuffs.DennyCrane.CuckooforCocoaPuffs.DennyCrane.U.S.AttorneyJoyner:Theyreseekingdamagesforactscommittedbyaforeigngovernmentagainstaforeigncitizenry.Theresnojurisdictionhere;nostanding.Andeveniftherewere,anysuchlawsuitwouldbebarredbysovereignimmunity,whichprohibitstheU.S.governmentoritsofficialsfrombeingsuedforforeignpolicydecisions.JudgeLindaOKeefe:MissColson,Ihavetoagree.HowdoInottossthisonitsface?LoriColson:First,theUnitedStatesgov