最新SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板.docx

《最新SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板.docx》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《最新SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板.docx（17页珍藏版）》请在淘文阁 - 分享文档赚钱的网站上搜索。

1、精品资料SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板.SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板修改稿回答审稿人的意见（最重要的部分）ListofResponsesDearEditorsandReviewers:Thankyouforyourletterandforthereviewerscommentsconcerningourmanuscriptentitled“PaperTitle”(ID:文章稿号).Thosecommentsareallvaluableandveryhelpfulforrevisingandimprovingourpaper,aswellastheim

2、portantguidingsignificancetoourresearches.Wehavestudiedcommentscarefullyandhavemadecorrectionwhichwehopemeetwithapproval.Revisedportionaremarkedinredinthepaper.Themaincorrectionsinthepaperandtherespondstothereviewerscommentsareasflowing:Respondstothereviewerscomments:Reviewer#1:1.Responsetocomment:(

3、简要列出意见)Response:2.Responsetocomment:(简要列出意见)Response:。逐条意见回答，切忌一定不能有遗漏针对不同的问题有下列几个礼貌术语可适当用用：Weareverysorryforournegligenceof.Weareverysorryforourincorrectwriting.ItisreallytrueasReviewersuggestedthatWehavemadecorrectionaccordingtotheReviewerscomments.Wehavere-writtenthispartaccordingtotheReviewerssu

4、ggestionAsReviewersuggestedthatConsideringtheReviewerssuggestion,wehave最后特意感谢一下这个审稿人的意见：Specialthankstoyouforyourgoodcomments.Reviewer#2:同上述Reviewer#3:Otherchanges:1.Line60-61,thestatementsof“”werecorrectedas“”2.Line107,“”wasadded3.Line129,“”wasdeletedWetriedourbesttoimprovethemanuscriptandmadesomec

5、hangesinthemanuscript.Thesechangeswillnotinfluencethecontentandframeworkofthepaper.Andherewedidnotlistthechangesbutmarkedinredinrevisedpaper.WeappreciateforEditors/Reviewerswarmworkearnestly,andhopethatthecorrectionwillmeetwithapproval.Onceagain,thankyouverymuchforyourcommentsandsuggestions以下是审稿人意见和

6、本人的回复。与大家分享。从中可以看出，这位审稿人认真读了文章，提出很多宝贵的意见。这些意见分布在文章的各个地方。我很诧异有人真正读了我的文章。看到这些意见，我觉得很感激，不是因为接收文章的原因，而是这些意见能真正有助于提高文章的质量。从中还看出，回答审稿人问题的“技巧”。对于回答问题，有的人就是一味反驳，却不加改进。记得ACSStyleGuide里面说，当审稿人问到问题的，哪怕是他理解错误，这也说明作者这么写，其他读者也会理解错误，引起歧义。因此，作者就是要修改句子，使表达不引起歧义。因此：有时间一味反驳，还不如指出具体改进在第几页、第几段。=Reviewerscomments:Reviewe

7、r#3:Whilerevisingthescript,itistobesuggestedthatauthorshouldclearlyindicatetheaim&scopeofthestudyandwhilemakingconclusion,itistobementionedhowthestudyisusefulforthepracticalpurposes.Inadditionthefollowingarethefewsuggestions/comments,whichmaybeincludedwhilerevision.Introductionpartfirstparalastline,

8、authormustavoidtowriteambiguousstatementi.e.,muchworkisstillahead,mayindicateproperly.2.Authorcouldnotdemonstratethereasonwhy,toselecttheorganiccompoundsuchasethylpyruvateforthisstudy?3.Experimentalpart:Itisdifficulttounderstandthein-situRAIRSexperimentswithhomemadeliquid-solidRAIRScell.Moredetailed

9、informationmaybeusefulfortheothersthosewhoareworkinginthearea.Photographoftheassembledcellmaybeincluded.4.Thedescriptiongivenfortheexperimentalsetup(page4)canbepresentedbyflowdiagraminstead,asaneasetounderstandthesetup.5.ReslutsPart(Page6):COadlayerswithidenticalmonolayercoverages,themonolayercovera

10、ge,isitbeenperformedwithsomeadsorptionmodel?Further,itwassuggestedthatCO-saturatedPtsurface,butnotmentionedaboutthesaturationexperiments.Isitobtainedafter60minofCObubbling?6.Page12,2ndpara:ThedisplacementofEtPybyCCl4flushing,isitconfirmedbytheEtPypeaks?Ifso,ithastobementionedclearlyinthepara.Alsoint

11、hesamepara,authorreferredforFig.7aand7bbutinthefigures,itdidntappear,onlyfigure7appeared.Ifeelitrefersforfigure7,portionAandB,tobecorrected.Similarly,inthetextreferredthefig2a,2b.etcbutonthefiguresheetitismentionedas2A,2B.etc.tobecorrected.7.Page14,1stpara:contaminationofthePtsurfacebycorrosionofo-r

12、ingsinhighconcentrationEtPy,butthestatementhasnotbeensupportedbyotherevidence/literature.8.Pages14through17:theobservedreactivityofvarioussolventsforadsorbedCOonthePtsurface(figs3&4)hastobediscussedmoreprecisely.Thisreviewerisunabletofollowthereasonwhytheyshoweddifferentreactivity,isitprincipallydue

13、totheorganicmoieties,orduetotheimpuritiesofcommerciallyavailablechemicalsoramixedeffect.Ithastobeclearlydemonstrated,however,theonlyexperimentperformedwithCO/water?CCl4woulddifficulttodescribeitindetail.9.Theauthortrytorestrainwithrepeatedargumentsinthetexte.g.,page3para1:Itwasgeneralizedthat.,alsoa

14、ppearedonpage21firstpara.10.Captionsofthefiguresaretoolong,thedetaileddescriptionalreadygiveninthetext,hencewouldnotbeincludedhere.Captionsshouldbeshortandcrispy.=DearEditor,Iquiteappreciateyourfavoriteconsiderationandthereviewersinsightfulcomments.NowIhaverevisedtheJCIS-06-247exactlyaccordingtother

15、eviewerscomments,andfoundthesecommentsareveryhelpful.Ihopethisrevisioncanmakemypapermoreacceptable.Therevisionswereaddressedpointbypointbelow.generalTheobjectiveofthisresearchwasaddedatthebeginningofthethirdparagraphofIntroduction.HowthestudyisusefulforpracticalpurposeswasaddedattheendofConclusionas

16、oneparagraph.1Ambiguousstatementi.e.,“muchworkisstillahead”wasdeleted.2Ethylpyruvatewasusedhereasatypicalcompound(containingtwocarbonylgroups)todemonstratethefeasibilityofusingourdiagnosingtooltodetectlow-coverageCO(comingfromdecarbonylationofEtPy)attheliquid-solidinterface.EtPyisareactantusedinliqu

17、id-phasechiralcatalysis,andslightdecompositionofEtPytoadsorbedCOwasreportedtoinfluencethecatalyticperformance.Inaddition,bystudyingthat,wecandirectlycompareourresultswithpreviousstudies.MoredetailsinthefirstparagraphofSection3.2.3TheIRcellwasdesignedaccordingtotheIRcellsusedbymanyelectrochemicalwork

18、ers.Referenceswereadded.AphotowasgivenintheSupportingInformation.4AflowdiagramoftheexperimentalsetupwasgiveninthenewFig.1.5TheCOadsorptionexperimentswereperformedinthesameadsorptionmode,bybubblingCOthroughacleanPtsurfaceindifferentdaystoachievethesamesaturationcoverageofCO.Initialexperimentsindicate

19、dthatgiventheCObubblingratewas0.85cm3/min,COcansaturateonPtafter30-45min.WebubbleCOfor60mintoguaranteethesameCOcoverage.IfwebubbleCOformoretime,orifweincreasetheCOflowingrateseveraltimes,theCOsaturationcoveragedoesntchange,indicating60minisalreadyenough.AfigureshowingtheCOuptakeasafunctionofbubbling

20、timewasgivenintheSupportingInformation.6ThedisplacementofEtPybyCCl4wasconfirmedbytheremovingofEtPypeaks.ThementionofFig.7aand7betc.throughoutthetextwereallcorrected.7ItisknownthatsomesolventssuchasacetonecancorrodetheVitono-ring.Wesawthedamageofo-ringafterusinghigh-concentrationEtPy.AreferencetotheV

21、itono-ringinformationwasgiven.8Theobservedreactivitytrendisduetoacombinationofbotheffects,withtheaccumulationoforganicmoietiesonPtsurfaceduringnumerousflushingcyclesthemoreimportantreason.Afewpropersentenceswereaddedtoclaritythispoint.9TherepeatedargumentsinthefirstparagraphinSection4.3weredeleted.1

22、0Thetoo-longcaptionsweresignificantlyshortened.Inall,Ifoundthereviewerscommentsarequitehelpful,andIrevisedmypaperpoint-by-point.Thankyouandthereviewagainforyourhelp!=结果：2Ethylpyruvatewasusedhereasatypicalcompound(containingtwocarbonylgroups)todemonstratethefeasibilityofusingourdiagnosingtooltodetect

23、low-coverageCO(comingfromdecarbonylationofEtPy)attheliquid-solidinterface.EtPyisareactantusedinliquid-phasechiralcatalysis,andslightdecompositionofEtPytoadsorbedCOwasreportedtoinfluencethecatalyticperformance.Inaddition,bystudyingthat,wecandirectlycompareourresultswithpreviousstudies.Moredetailsinth

24、efirstparagraphofSection3.2.3TheIRcellwasdesignedaccordingtotheIRcellsusedbymanyelectrochemicalworkers.Referenceswereadded.AphotowasgivenintheSupportingInformation.4AflowdiagramoftheexperimentalsetupwasgiveninthenewFig.1.5TheCOadsorptionexperimentswereperformedinthesameadsorptionmode,bybubblingCOthr

25、oughacleanPtsurfaceindifferentdaystoachievethesamesaturationcoverageofCO.InitialexperimentsindicatedthatgiventheCObubblingratewas0.85cm3/min,COcansaturateonPtafter30-45min.WebubbleCOfor60mintoguaranteethesameCOcoverage.IfwebubbleCOformoretime,orifweincreasetheCOflowingrateseveraltimes,theCOsaturatio

26、ncoveragedoesntchange,indicating60minisalreadyenough.AfigureshowingtheCOuptakeasafunctionofbubblingtimewasgivenintheSupportingInformation.6ThedisplacementofEtPybyCCl4wasconfirmedbytheremovingofEtPypeaks.ThementionofFig.7aand7betc.throughoutthetextwereallcorrected.7Itisknownthatsomesolventssuchasacet

27、onecancorrodetheVitono-ring.Wesawthedamageofo-ringafterusinghigh-concentrationEtPy.AreferencetotheVitono-ringinformationwasgiven.8Theobservedreactivitytrendisduetoacombinationofbotheffects,withtheaccumulationoforganicmoietiesonPtsurfaceduringnumerousflushingcyclesthemoreimportantreason.Afewpropersen

28、tenceswereaddedtoclaritythispoint.9TherepeatedargumentsinthefirstparagraphinSection4.3weredeleted.10Thetoo-longcaptionsweresignificantlyshortened.Inall,Ifoundthereviewerscommentsarequitehelpful,andIrevisedmypaperpoint-by-point.Thankyouandthereviewagainforyourhelp!=结果：CI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板修改稿回答审稿人的意见（最重要的

29、部分）ListofResponsesDearEditorsandReviewers:Thankyouforyourletterandforthereviewerscommentsconcerningourmanuscriptentitled“PaperTitle”(ID:文章稿号).Thosecommentsareallvaluableandveryhelpfulforrevisingandimprovingourpaper,aswellastheimportantguidingsignificancetoourresearches.Wehavestudiedcommentscarefully

30、andhavemadecorrectionwhichwehopemeetwithapproval.Revisedportionaremarkedinredinthepaper.Themaincorrectionsinthepaperandtherespondstothereviewerscommentsareasflowing:Respondstothereviewerscomments:Reviewer#1:1.Responsetocomment:(简要列出意见)Response:2.Responsetocomment:(简要列出意见)Response:。逐条意见回答，切忌一定不能有遗漏针对

31、不同的问题有下列几个礼貌术语可适当用用：Weareverysorryforournegligenceof.Weareverysorryforourincorrectwriting.ItisreallytrueasReviewersuggestedthatWehavemadecorrectionaccordingtotheReviewerscomments.Wehavere-writtenthispartaccordingtotheReviewerssuggestionAsReviewersuggestedthatConsideringtheReviewerssuggestion,wehave最

32、后特意感谢一下这个审稿人的意见：Specialthankstoyouforyourgoodcomments.Reviewer#2:同上述Reviewer#3:Otherchanges:1.Line60-61,thestatementsof“”werecorrectedas“”2.Line107,“”wasadded3.Line129,“”wasdeletedWetriedourbesttoimprovethemanuscriptandmadesomechangesinthemanuscript.Thesechangeswillnotinfluencethecontentandframeworkofthepaper.Andherewedidnotlistthechangesbutmarkedinredinrevisedpaper.WeappreciateforEditors/Reviewerswarmworkearnestly,andhopethatthecorrectionwillmeetwithapproval.Onceagain,thankyouverymuchforyourcommentsandsuggestions.