SCI论文全攻略之审稿回复实例.pdf

《SCI论文全攻略之审稿回复实例.pdf》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《SCI论文全攻略之审稿回复实例.pdf（14页珍藏版）》请在淘文阁 - 分享文档赚钱的网站上搜索。

1、 SCI 论文全攻略之审稿回复实例.txt 精神失常的疯子不可怕，可怕的是精神正常的疯子！附1：SCI 扩展版和 SCI 核心版收录期刊的区别 SCI 扩展版（以下简称 SCIE）和 SCI 核心版（以下简称 SCI）收录期刊还是有区别的，SCI期刊论文全部被 SCI 收录，SCIE 期刊论文只是部分被 SCI 收录，这就是有的 SCIE 期刊一年有几百篇论文，却只有几十篇甚至十几篇论文被 SCI 收录的原因。具体到 SCIE 期刊上的一篇论文能否被 SCI 收录，还是要看美国 ISI 发布的报告，现在科技部信息研究所也公布这一报告，很多图书馆的 SCI 检索机构也可以查。不过在国内，很多单位

2、都把 SCI 期刊论文和 SCIE 期刊论文一视同仁，只要发表在 SCI 期刊或 SCIE 期刊上，该论文都当作 SCI 收录，这是管理者的无能抑或无为就不得而知了。但就我们单位而言（国内 TOP10 高校），这两者还是区别对待的，论文是否 SCI 收录还是看 CISI的报告或 SCI 检索机构的证 附 2：精华如何回复 SCI 投稿审稿人意见(1)1.所有问题必须逐条回答。2.尽量满足意见中需要补充的实验。3.满足不了的也不要回避，说明不能做的合理理由。4.审稿人推荐的文献一定要引用，并讨论透彻。以下是本人对审稿人意见的回复一例，仅供参考。续两点经验：1，最重要的是逐条回答，即使你答不了，也

3、要老实交代；不要太狡猾，以至于耽误事；2，绝大部分实验是不要真追加的，除非你受到启发，而想该投另外高档杂志-因为你既然已经写成文章，从逻辑上肯定是一个完整的“story”了。以上指国际杂志修稿。国内杂志太多，以至于稿源吃紧，基本没有退稿，所以你怎么修都是接受。我的文章水平都不高，主要是没有明显的创新性，也很苦恼。但是除了开始几篇投在国内杂志外，其他都在国际杂志（也都是 SCI）发表。以我了解的情况，我单位其他同志给国内杂志投稿，退稿的极少，只有一次被某某科学进展拒绝。究其原因，除了我上面说的，另外可能是我单位写稿子还是比较严肃，导师把关也比较严的缘故。自我感觉总结（不一定对）：1）国内杂志审稿

4、极慢（少数除外），但现在也有加快趋势；2）国内杂志编辑人员认真负责的人不多，稿子寄去后，少则几个月，多则一年多没有任何消息；3）国内杂志要求修改的稿子，如果你自己不修，他最后也给你发；4）国外杂志要求补充实验的，我均以解释而过关，原因见少帖）。还因为：很少杂志编辑把你的修改稿再寄给当初审稿人的，除非审稿人特别请求。编辑不一定懂你的东西，他只是看到你认真修改，回答疑问了，也就接受了（当然高档杂志可能不是这样，我的经验只限定一般杂志（影响因子 1-5）。欢迎大家批评指正。我常用的回复格式，呵呵。Dear reviewer:I am very grateful to your comments fo

5、r the manuscript.According with your advice,we amended the relevant part in manuscript.Some of your questions were answered below.1）2）.引用审稿人推荐的文献的确是很重要的，要想办法和自己的文章有机地结合起来。至于实验大部分都可以不用补做，关键是你要让审稿人明白你的文章的重点是什么，这个实验对你要强调的重点内容不是很必要，或者你现在所用的方法已经可以达到目的就行了。最后要注意，审稿人也会犯错误，不仅仅是笔误也有专业知识上的错误，因为编辑找的审稿人未必是你这个领域的

6、专家。只要自己是正确的就要坚持。在回复中委婉地表达一下你的意见，不过要注意商讨语气哦！我得回复格式是这样的：Dear Professor xx:Thank you very much for your letter dated xxx xx xxxx,and the referees reports.Based on your comment and request,we have made extensive modification on the original manuscript.Here,we attached revised manuscript.in the formats o

7、f both PDF and MS word,for your approval.A document answering every question from the referees was also summarized and enclosed.A revised manuscript.with the correction sections red marked was attached as the supplemental material and for easy check/editing purpose.Should you have any questions,plea

8、se contact us without hesitate.然后再附上 Q/A，基本上嘱条回答，写的越多越好（老师语）。结果修改一次就接收了：）我的回复，请老外帮忙修改了 Dear Editor:Thank you for your kind letter of“.”on November*,2005.We revised the manuscript.in accordance with the reviewers comments,and carefully proof-read the manuscript.to minimize typographical,grammatical,a

9、nd bibliographical errors.Here below is our description on revision according to the reviewers comments.Part A(Reviewer 1).The reviewers comment:.The authors Answer:.2.The reviewers comment:.The authors Answer:.Part B(Reviewer 2)1.The reviewers comment:.The authors Answer:.2.The reviewers comment:.T

10、he authors Answer:.Many grammatical or typographical errors have been revised.All the lines and pages indicated above are in the revised manuscript.Thank you and all the reviewers for the kind advice.Sincerely yours,*精华如何回复 SCI 投稿审稿人意见(2)一个回复的例子(已接收)Major comments:1.The authors need to strengthen th

11、eir results by including MMP secretion,and tran-matrigel migration by a positive control progenitor cell population i.e.enriched human CD34 cells obtained from mobilized PBL,since this is a more clinically relevant source of CD34 cells which has also been shown to secrete both MMP-9 and MMP-2(ref.11

12、).CD34 enriched cells from steady state peripheral blood which also secrete MMPs are also of interest.2.In fig1Cplease specify which cell line represents MMP-negative cells.This needs to be clarified,as well as a better explanation of the method of the protocol.3.The ELISA results are represented as

13、 fold increase compared to control.Instead,we suggest that standards should be used and results should be presented as absolute concentrations and only then can these results be compared to those of the zymography.4.When discussing the results,the authors should distinguish clearly between spontaneo

14、us migration vs chemotactic migration.Furthermore,the high spontaneous migration obtained with cord blood CD34 cells should be compared to mobilized PBL CD34 enriched cells and discussed.5.The authors claim that the clonogenic assay was performed to determine the optimum concentration for inhibition

15、 of MMP activity by phenanthroline and anti MMP-9 mAb,however they should clarify that this assay can only determine the toxicity of the inhibitors and not their optimal inhibitory concentrations.Minor comments:1.There are many spelling and syntax errors,especially in the results and discussion,whic

16、h need correction.a.Of special importance,is the percent inhibition of migration,which is described as percent of migration.i.e.pg 7:Migration of CB CD34 was reduced to 73.3%?Instead should read Migration of CB CD34 was reduced by 73.3%?b.The degree symbol needs to be added to the numbers in Materia

17、ls and methods.2.It would be preferable to combine figure1Aand B,in order to confirm the reliability of fig.1B by a positive control(HT1080).Answer to referee 1 comment:1.Mobilized peripheral blood is a more clinical source of CD34+cells,so it is necessary to compare the MMP-9 secretion and trans-mi

18、gration ability of CB CD34+cells with that of mobilized PB CD34+cells.However,we couldnt obtain enough mobilized PB to separate PB CD34+cells and determine the MMP-9 secretion and migration ability,so we couldnt complement the study on PB CD34+cells in this paper.Results obtained by Janowska-Wieczor

19、ek et al found that mobilized CD34+cells in peripheral blood express MMP-9.Furthermore,Domenechs study showed that MMP-9 secretion is involved in G-CSF induced HPC mobilization.Their conclusions have been added in the discussion.In our present study,our central conclusion from our data is that fresh

20、ly isolated CD34+stem/progenitor cells obtained from CB produce MMP-9.2.MMP-9 negative cell used in fig1Cwas Jurkat cell.In zymographic analysis,MMP-9 was not detected in the medium conditioned by Jurkat cell.To exclude that the contaminating cells may play a role in the observed MMP-9 production,we

21、 screened the media conditioned by different proportion of CB mononuclear cells with MMP-9 negative cells by zymography.This result may be confusion.Actually,only by detecting the medium conditioned by 2X105 CB mononuclear cells(MNC)/ml(since the purities of CD34+cell are more than 90%),it could exc

22、lude the MNC role.In the revised manuscript,we only detected MMP-9 activity and antigen level in the medium conditioned by 2X105 CB mononuclear cells(MNC)/ml.There is no MMP-9 secretion be detected in the medium conditioned by 2X105 CB MNC/ml.It excluded the possibility that the MMP-9 activity in CB

23、 CD34+cells conditioned medium is due to the contamination by MNC.3.In this revised paper,we have detected the MMP-9 antigen levels by using commercial specific ELISA kits(R&D System,sensitivity,0.156ng/ml).Recombinant MMP-9 from R&D System was used as a standard.The results are expressed in the abs

24、olute concentration.The absolute concentration result has been added in the paper.As shown in Fig2,MMP-9 levels were detectable in both CB CD34+cell conditioned medium and BM CD34+cell conditioned medium.However,MMP-9 level was significantly higher in CB CD34+cell conditioned medium than in BM CD34+

25、cell conditioned medium(0.4060.133ng/ml versus 0.1950.023ng/ml).Although gelatinolytic activity was not detected in media conditioned by CD34+cells from BM,sensitivity of ELISA favors the detection of MMP-9 antigen in the BM CD34+.4.In our study,to establish the direct link between MMP-9 and CB CD34

26、+cells migration,we only determined the role of MMP-9 inspontaneous migration of CB CD34+cells,but not in chemotactic migration.Actually,regulation of hematopoietic stem cell migration,homing and anchorage of repopulation cells to the bone marrow involves a complex interplay between adhesion molecul

27、es,chemokines,cytokines and proteolytic enzymes.Results obtained by the groups of Voermans reveal that not only the spontaneous migration but also the SDF-1 induced migration of CB CD34+cells is greatly increased in comparison to CD34+cells from BM and peripheral blood.5.CD34+cells we obtained in ea

28、ch cord blood sample were very limited.It is not enough to screen the inhibitors concentrations to select the optimal inhibitory concentrations.In the blocking experiments,based on the concentrations used by others and the manufacturers recommendation,we then determined the inhibitors concentrations

29、 by excluding the toxicity of the inhibitors in that concentration,which was determined by clonogenic assay.Minor comments:1.The spelling and syntax errors have been checked and corrected.2.Since the results in figure1Aand B were obtained from two separated and parallel experiments,it is not fitness

30、 to combine two figures.这是我的一篇修稿回复，杂志是 JBMR-A,影响因子 3.652,已发表，供参考！Reply to the comments on JBMR-A-05-0172 Comment:Reference#10 is missing from the Introduction but used much later in the manuscript.Should these be in order used in manuscript?Reply:The missing reference has been added into the revised

31、 manuscript.Comment(continued):What is the sample size for all tests performed?Reply:The sample size for drug release and PCL degradation tests was 3.03.0 cm2,with a thickness of about0.1mmand a weight of about 40mg.This dada have been added into the revised manuscript.Comment(continued):Figure 7.Th

32、ere is no scientific evidence presented in the TEM figure to convince this reviewer of sub-jets.This statement on Page 9 cannot be made without clear evidence during the jet formation/separation.Figure 7 is just a large fiber and small fiber fused together,no other conclusion than this can be made.R

33、eply:Necessary change in the statements has been made in the revised manuscript.as well as in the referred figure accordingly.Comment(continued):Table 3:Need standard deviation for all values reported not just for a select few.Equation after Table 3 not necessary.Just reference method used.Reply:Don

34、e accordingly.Comment(continued):Page 11:faster weight loss What was the sample size?Where is the statistical analysis of this data?This reviewer does not see a significant difference in any of the data presented,thus weight loss would be considered equivalent.Reply:Although not too much difference

35、was seen,the conclusion that“the GS/PCL membrane exhibited a relatively faster weight loss compared with the RT/PCL membrane”was indeed applicable through“one-way analysis of variance(ANOVA)”analysis.Following the reviewers comment,a new sub-section has been added to the manuscript.to address the st

36、atistical analysis for the data.Comment(continued):Page 12:What is the sample size for release data?Looks like results based on a sample size of one?Need stand deviations on the data presented in Figure 11.Why wasnt release performed and compared for all electrospun conditions investigated otherwise

37、?Reply:Three repeated tests were performed for each set of measurements and the resulting data were averaged.As stated in the revised manuscript,each sample had a square area of 33cm2 with a slightly different thickness.Standard deviations have been added to the data shown in Fig.11.The pres

38、ent manuscript.aimed to show that medical drugs can be encapsulated in ultrafine fibers through a co-axial electrospinning process.The drug release data intended to show that the encapsulation was successful.We did not consider any specific application in this preliminary paper,and in fact the two d

39、rugs were just chosen as model illustration.As such,there seemed not necessary to perform.release experiments for all of the membranes electrospun with different conditions(i.e.the core concentrations)Comment(continued):Table 3:Yangs or Youngs Modulus(page 10 says Youngs).Reply:Corrected accordingly

40、.Comment(continued):Figure 11:What is the%release,not just concentration.Why just this small sample of release data?Where is the release data for the other conditions?Reply:Unfortunately,we did not measure the amount of the shell material in obtaining the composite nanofibers.Namely,the flow rate of

41、 the shell solution during the electrospinning was not accurately controlled using an injecting pump.Hence the%release was not applicable.Please refer to the previous reply related to Page 12 and Figure 11 for the remaining comments.We acknowledge the reviewers comments and suggestions very much,whi

42、ch are valuable in improving the quality of our manuscript.附 3：SCI 生物医学英文论文发表成功经验发表成功经验 SCI 生物医学英文论文发表成功经验共享系列一-（Clinical Chemistry）将自己近 10 年的科研工作中有关论文整理总结发表方面的一些信息贡献出来，与大家共享！如有时间，我拟将一些已经发表的文章，按照撰写与发表的实际经历与过程，即通过案例分 析每一个杂志的特色，审稿偏好，review 意见及答复要点等逐一分析。可能包含的杂志系列有：nature methods，clinical chemistry，anal

43、ytical chemistry，J.Clin.Immuno，Biomed.Microdev，Front.Biosci，Mol.Cell.Biochem，J.Expert，Rev.Proteomics，J biochemistry等。本章先讲解美国 Clinical Chemistry 杂志，一个临床化学界的王牌杂志，近年其影响因子逐年攀升，现为 7.7 分。Clinical Chemistry 由美国 AACC 每月出版，接受的文章包括与人体疾病相关的实验室研究，分析与分子诊断，仪器，资料处理，数据分析，临床研究等投稿。ISSN：0009-9147 网络版 ISSN：1530-8561 【U

44、RL】http:/intl.clinchem.org/【镜像 URL】http:/www.clinchem.org/【出版者】American Association for Clinical Chemistry(AACC)【收费情况】免费,全文 【内容简介】Clinical Chemistry is an international journal of laboratory medicine and molecular diagnostics.Clinical Chemistry-This highly respected and often-cited scientific journa

45、l is published monthly and contains peer-reviewed methodology,research papers and other articles relevant to clinical chemistry and related laboratory sciences.Its circulation is more than 15,000.David E.Bruns,MD,Editor,(Charlottesville Office)dbrunsclinchem.aacc.org Sandra Weaver,Senior Editorial A

46、ssistant sweaverclinchem.aacc.org Donna Brandl,Editorial Assistant dbrandlclinchem.aacc.org Shane P.Cyr,Editorial Assistant scyrclinchem.aacc.org Mac Fancher,Publisher,(WashingtonOffice)mfancheraacc.org Miriam Gonzalez,Publications Coordinator mgonzalezaacc.org 【目录、摘要或全文上网等情况】Free TOC,1965-Free Abst

47、ract,1975-Free Fulltext,1997-1999 Fulltext,1997-【杂志被索引的情况】Indexed in Chemical Abstracts.【备注】For faster access to Clinical Chemistry Online from these countries use this URL:http:/intl.clinchem.orgAustralia,Brazil,China,France,Germany,Hong Kong,Ireland,Israel,Italy,Japan,Mexico,Russia,Singapore,South

48、 Africa,South Korea,Spain,Sweden,Switzerland,Taiwan,The Netherlands,UK 该杂志是由美国临床化学协会（American Association for Clinical Chemistry，AACC）主办的，于 1948 年成立，总部位于华盛顿，拥有 1 万余会员。先在网站注册，登记，按照提示一步步提供文章名称，摘要，作者姓名，所属领域，关键词，主文，图表等等。转换为 PDF 后就可以提交，然后给你一个查询号，接着就是等待了。等了 20 多天，查阅状态看到了第一次回信：Home Author Area Reviewer Are

49、a Personal Info.ClinChem Home Sign Out Submit New Manuscript.Information for Authors Queue Summary Feedback Help FAQ Decision Letter Return to Queue To:作者姓名（电子邮件）From:clinchemedclinchem.aacc.org Subject:Clinical Chemistry-Manuscript.Decision Cc:RE:Clinical Chemistry MS ID#CLINCHEM/2002/036332 TITLE:

50、Dear Dr.xxx:Your manuscript.has been examined by two expert reviewers.Please visit http:/submit.clinchem.org to view their comments.For the reasons detailed in these comments,we cannot accept this manuscript.for publication in Clinical Chemistry in this form.Also,your Reference 28 is not formatted p