(完整word版)如何回复审稿人意见.pdf

《(完整word版)如何回复审稿人意见.pdf》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《(完整word版)如何回复审稿人意见.pdf（4页珍藏版）》请在淘文阁 - 分享文档赚钱的网站上搜索。

1、如何回复英文论文编辑部的修改意见Response to Editor and Reviewer这是我的英文修改稿回复信Dear Editor,RE:Manuscript IDWe would like to thank XXX(name of Journal)for giving us the opportunity to revise our manuscript.We thank the reviewers for their careful read and thoughtful comments on previous draft.We have carefully taken the

2、ir comments into consideration in preparing our revision,which has resulted in a paper that is clearer,more compelling,and broader.The following summarizes how we responded to reviewer comments.Below is our response to their comments.Thanks for all the help.Best wishes,Dr.XXXCorresponding Author下面是如

3、何对 Reviewer 的意见进行 point by point 回答：一些习惯用语如下：Revision authors responseReviewer#1:Major comments1.The referee correctly noted that our language about XXX was ambiguous.Therefore,we changed the text and the figures to emphasize that.To further support the concept that,we have analyzed.As depicted in S

4、upplementary Fig.S12.As suggested by the reviewer we have emphasized our observations of XXX in results and discussion sections.We have added new findings(see above point)in Supplementary Fig S.to support3.As requested by the reviewer we have added a scheme(Supplementary Fig.)that summarizes Minor c

5、omments1.We have removed the word SUFFICIENT from the title.2.We have added and improved the scale bars in the figure 1 and 2.3.We have added statistics to Fig 5C.4.We have corrected the typescript errors in the XXX paragraph.Reviewer#2:1.Because of the reviewers request,we have performed new experi

6、ments to better clarify The new Fig.shows that This finding suggests that2.As suggested by the reviewer we have added new data of XXX to clarify the point that 3.We agree with the reviewer that Because of the reviewers request we have used XXX to confirm that The new data are depicted in Supplementa

7、ry Fig.4.Because of reviewers request,we have analyzed the efficiency of RNAi by quantitative RT-PCR the efficiency of RNAi.We have now added the new panel in Supplementary Fig.Reviewer#3:1.Because of the referees comment,we have moved the panel of Fig.5 into the new Figure 6 and we have added new e

8、xperiments to address.The new Fig.6 shows that.2.In response to the reviewers requests,we have studied.The new data are depicted in Suppplementary Fig.3.We agree with reviewer that.However,a recent paper has shown that.We have added this reference and mo dified the sentence to underline.4.We have ch

9、anges Figure 1 with a picture that.The previous one was too week and the green fluorescence was lost during the conversion in PDF format.5.Because of reviews request,we have changed as much as possible the magnification in order to maintain the same scale bar but also to preserve details.6.The diffe

10、rence between XXX and XXX is not statistically significant.In order to better clarify this issue we changed the graphics of our statistical analysis in Fig.文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8

11、I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B

12、8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:C

13、U7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 H

14、N8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN

15、7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码

16、:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5

17、 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6另外一篇 5分杂志的回复：1nd Revision authors responseReferee#1:We want to begin by thanking Referee#1 for writing that“the finding in our manuscript is generally interesting and important in the field.”We also appreciated the constructivecriticism and suggestion.We addressed all the poi

18、nts raised by the reviewer,as summarized below.1.According to the referees suggestion,the experiment demonstrating;in the new experiment,this result is presented in the revised Fig.2.The referee suggests demonstrating that.This experiment was performed in XXX by comparing 3.The referee comments that

19、 it is unclear whether the effect of.is due to.To address the referees comment,we revised Fig.and demonstrated that.To further confirm.Two new data have been added in the revised Fig.In summary,the results in Fig.demonstrate that.4.Thanks to the referees comment,the wrong figure numbers were correct

20、ed in the revised manuscript.Referee#2:We want to thank Referee#2 for constructive and insightful criticism and advice.We addressed all the points raised by the reviewer as summarized below.1.The referee recommends to show.We performed the experiment and its result is included in the revised Fig.2.A

21、ccording to the referees suggestion,the experiments in Fig.were repeated several times and representative data are included in the revised Fig.3.Based on the referees comment that,echoing comment#4 of Referee#1,above.As stated above,we have included new results,which include:4.All minor points raise

22、d by the reviewer were corrected accordingly.2nd Revision authors responseWe would like to thank the referees for their thoughtful review of our manuscript.We believe that the additional changes we have made in response to the reviewers comments have made this a significantly stronger manuscript.Bel

23、ow is our point-by-point response to the referees comments.Referee#1:Referee#1 request two minor editorial changes.Both changes have been made accordingly in the revised manuscript.Referee#2:We sincerely apologize to Referee#2 for not completely addressing all of the points raised in the previous re

24、sponse.We have done so below and added additional data in hopes that this reviewer will be supportive of publication.文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 H

25、N8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN

26、7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码

27、:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5

28、 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4

29、ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档

30、编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W61.Referee#2 req

31、uests evidence that.According to the referees suggestion,a XXX assay was performed in XXX cells to demonstrate that.The result is presented in Fig.2.Page 17,“the”E3 was changed to“an”E3.3.Referee#2 asks whether.We would like to note that we investigated.in our previous study and found no evidence th

32、at.Therefore,in this manuscript we focused on.文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7

33、I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8

34、I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B

35、8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:C

36、U7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 H

37、N8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6文档编码:CU7I5S10X5Y5 HN8I8Y6L8J4 ZN7B8L7W9W6